Loomio
Tue 30 Sep 2014 10:09PM

Why the distinction between "Disagree" and "Block"?

DN Diogo Nunes Public Seen by 278

The first time I used Loomio I was right away confused by the distinction between Disagree and Block when voting on "decisions".

If I support the proposal, I "Agree".
If I don't have an opinion, I "Abstain".
If I reject the proposal, I "Disagree".

Why the need for a "Block" decision? If I disagree, of course I want to block it, it's implied! If I find the need to detail my "disagree" I'll leave a comment. Breaking up the votes into two simillar choices seems counter-productive and counter-intuitive to me.

DN

Daniel Nephin
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 4:08PM

Removeing "block" from loomio would be removing one of it's greatest strengths. There are always more than two positions to any argument, and providing fewer options leads to an inferior process.

EG

Ed Galligan
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 5:35PM

text too long for this box - see comment

EG

Ed Galligan
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 5:37PM

text too long for this box - see comment: https://www.loomio.org/d/xPyUG8tE/#comment-287740

KA

Kylee Astrobox
Disagree
Sun 19 Oct 2014 5:54PM

I think it's important to make a strong statement of you feel strongly about it.

I like the block feature. It is very, very rarely used in the groups I'm in, so when it is used we know we need to discuss more

FS

Frederick Stark
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 6:30PM

Block is a crucial part of consensus decision making theory. Since Loomio is built around this theory, it must remain.

CZ

Chris Zumbrunn
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 8:55PM

Distinguishing between disagree and block is a core aspect of the reason d'être of Loomio.

RN

Rob Nevin
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 9:42PM

Block is a distinctive and should be retained (as here!) for strong negative. One has every opportunity 250 characters provide to articulate their position, however the vote is cast - including Block.

ST

Stacco Troncoso
Block
Sun 19 Oct 2014 10:37PM

Blocking is one of Loomio's key features. A Block demands an explanation and stimulates further dialogue and solution seeking.

TA

Tracey Ambrose
Block
Mon 20 Oct 2014 12:57AM

Block is a key element to consensus decision making. It indicates that someone is not just unhappy with a proposal but is vehemently opposed to it. Removing this feature in Loomio would make the system of much less of an interest/use to me.

AI

Alanna Irving
Block
Mon 20 Oct 2014 5:04AM

When a single voice can always be heard, everyone has to think beyond the groupthink of the majority. Even if you never use a block, its very existence is essential. That said, groups can define for themselves what positions mean in their context.

Load More