Loomio

Statement on the aadhaar judgement

PP
Pirate Praveen Public Seen by 260

We should come up with a response to the judgment and highlight our manifesto which calls for scrapping aadhaar.

Draft

We are disappointed by the majority judgment which failed to protect people's fundamental right to privacy. We welcome the minority judgment by Justice DY Chandracud and hope it will eventually become the reality. Indian Pirates are committed to scrap Aadhaar completely as proclaimed in our Manifesto and invite all democratic forces to join hands in our quest to scrap it.

PP

Pirate Praveen Thu 27 Sep 2018

https://thewire.in/law/justice-chandrachud-dissent-aadhaar-verdict I think Justice Chandrachud's minority judgment will help us in convincing people.

V

Vidyut Thu 27 Sep 2018

I've made some points here.

Important - judgment undermines parliamentary process by recognizing the Aadhaar Act as a valid money bill and opens the route to rogue governments bypassing the Rajya Sabha to get laws made.

Stress on tech illiteracy - the judgment does not consider the technological ramifications adequately. Also the impact on the poor - they are the ones who have actually died from denial of their PDS and pensions and such and Section 7 has been upheld by the Supreme Court. We see a class bias in their lives and rights not mattering.

There's more in the post.

Vidyut
Social Media: Twitter ( https://twitter.com/Vidyut ) Facebook ( https://facebook.com/theVidyut ) Google+ ( https://google.com/+AamJanata ) Diaspora ( https://poddery.com/i/62f15bc003f0 )

Blogs: Intellectual Anarchy ( https://aamjanata.com ) || Nisarga ( https://nisarga.info ) || tech ( https://vidyut.net ) || Homeschooling ( https://homeschoolingindia.in ) || Fek Le ( https://fekle.in )

KVM

Kannan V M Sat 15 Dec 2018

Could you finish reading the report? I would very much like to see your notes on it.

V

Vidyut Thu 27 Sep 2018

Ah right. oops

B

Bady Fri 28 Sep 2018

as @akshay has mentioned in the end of the blog post, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology has invited feedback on a draft Personal Data Protection Bill. i think we should provide our feedback on the same. we could start a new thread if needed, the deadline is near which is September 30.