Loomio
Thu 20 Feb 2020 4:07AM

Should we use Integrative Consent for decision-making in Social.Coop?

MN Matt Noyes Public Seen by 73

This purpose of this thread is to experiment with an integrative consent process as described here: https://help.loomio.org/en/guides/consent_process/ The model proposal is that Social.Coop adopt the integrative consent method for decision-making on Loomio. We can use an integrative consent process to discuss and maybe reach consent on this proposal. This will give us practice.

MN

Matt Noyes Tue 25 Feb 2020 11:52PM

PROCESS: "During this phase, all team members are invited to present any objections they have, with objections being defined as what “might cause harm to the team or organization”.

In our use of Integrative Consent, should we decide to use it, we might want to alter the criteria, but for now let's use theirs:

MN

Poll Created Tue 25 Feb 2020 11:57PM

Who can facilitate this discussion of the proposal? Closed Wed 26 Feb 2020 4:53PM

Outcome
by Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 4:54PM

@Mica Fisher is our facilitator

IMPORTANT: we need a facilitator at this step. That person should not be the proposer (Matt N). In the interests of learning the process by following it, who would be willing to facilitate, following the instructions?

Results

Results Option Voters
Yes 1 MF
Undecided 99 DS ST JD CZ BH F NS SH KT C G AM MSC CCC AW MC SC PA RB MN

1 of 100 people have participated (1%)

MF

Mica Fisher
Yes
Wed 26 Feb 2020 3:43PM

I can be the facilitator!

AU

Ana Ulin Wed 26 Feb 2020 2:18AM

I am willing to facilitate, but I am going to be traveling starting tomorrow (Feb 26th) and until March 11th, with very limited online availability, so I won't be able to contribute during that time. If we want to move the process forward during that time, someone else would need to facilitate.

(FWIW, in the IDM process as practiced at my current work, the proposer is also the person that integrates feedback and comes up with an updated proposal. I don't know how usual or advisable that is, this is my only experience with IDM.)

MN

Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 4:10AM

Hi Ana, thanks for being willing to facilitate! I think if we wait until you are back it might be too long? About the integration and updated proposal, I am happy to do that. I think the facilitator's job is just to help us stick to the process and to ask people if their objections are valid, is that right?

AU

Ana Ulin Wed 26 Feb 2020 5:19AM

Yep, the role would be mainly to keep the process on track. I agree that waiting for two weeks is too long -- maybe someone else can facilitate, or you can do that yourself if needed @Matt Noyes .

MN

Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 3:33PM

Maybe in this case it is okay because this is a trial proposal so I am not as invested in the outcome and more interested in learning from the process. But better if someone else wants to try out facilitating...

MN

Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 3:38PM

Meta: "who expects whom to participate?" This is a key issue -- seems like this process assumes something like a team or working group trying to organize its work. My proposal left the "who" undefined... So that should be added to the process at a question to consider at the first step: "Who is expected to participate in this process? Why?"

MN

Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 4:08PM

Thanks @Mica Fisher !!!

MN

Matt Noyes Wed 26 Feb 2020 4:11PM

Meta: "Should I be voting? Should I be objecting? Should I be commenting? It's all a bit overwhelming." -- The idea of this Step is that people should object and comment. So, maybe instead of "Consent, Abstain, Objection" I should have just asked for Objections?

Load More