Loomio
Sat 18 Jan 2014 7:33PM

Stream should be named differently

M maliktunga Public Seen by 93

Naming the main stream "Stream" is wrongly suggesting that there is only one stream on Diaspora*, while there are many, many others :

  • Stream
  • My Activity
  • @Mentions
  • My Aspects
  • #Followed Tags
  • Profile
  • Search
  • Other people's profiles

Thus, I propose the Stream to be renamed Home or Main Stream.

R

Ryuno-Ki Wed 22 Jan 2014 7:28AM

@gillesphilippemori It's related in this way, that new stream names could be arranged in a way, that fits the different resolutions. Say, when more streams are embedded in the header navigation, it can be done clever :)

G

goob Wed 22 Jan 2014 11:05AM

To me, 'Home' for a website sounds very old-fashioned, like 1990s.

'Main stream' has other connotations in English, so I wouldn't be in favour of that.

As @jellelangbroek pointed out, there is only one stream; the other views are filtered from that one stream. E.g. 'My activity' displays only the posts in your stream on which you have made a contribution; 'My aspects' displays only the posts in your stream made by people in your aspects; and so on.

I don't see any confusion from calling the stream 'Stream'. It seems to me to be trying to fix a problem which doesn't exist.

I'm happy for people to propose alternative ideas, to see if anything better comes up, but unless there's some amazing idea, I vote for retaining 'Stream' for the, er, stream.

G

goob Wed 22 Jan 2014 11:06AM

ps: I don't care what other social networks do.

JL

Jelle Langbroek Wed 22 Jan 2014 11:14AM

@maliktunga just to clarify; have you actually heard the complaint from other people being confused by 'Stream'?
I ask this because as @goob points out, let's not create problems that aren't there ;)
as for me as podmin, I haven't heard the complaint before.

M

maliktunga Wed 22 Jan 2014 11:09PM

@jellelangbroek Actual "complaints" no, but people to which I showed diaspora* did find that counter-intuitive. In fact, my position is reversed : why make it different from the standard? There is no problem in naming the main page "Home"... ;-)

@Goob 1990s, really? That's not really an argument in my opinion. Desktops are called desktops since the 70s and that doesn't make it a bad name. It may be "old-fashioned", but there is a reason why it's still used. Oldie but goodie :)

AA

Alberto Aru Thu 23 Jan 2014 11:42PM

Timeline?

M

Poll Created Fri 24 Jan 2014 6:09PM

Should we rename the Stream? Closed Fri 31 Jan 2014 9:10PM

Outcome
by maliktunga Tue 25 Apr 2017 5:53AM

NO : Stream will not be renamed.

YES : Stream should be renamed (e.g. "Home").

NO : Stream is the best name that could ever be chosen. OR There's no need to change.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 8.6% 3 PH C M
Abstain 8.6% 3 KAK X AA
Disagree 82.9% 29 ST JH JR G DS M PG IGM AL R SM SVB F S W JL J FTL N V
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 248 BK FS MS TS AA S CB HF BO DM GC JH F RF M EG G AX PC PP

35 of 283 people have participated (12%)

M

maliktunga
Agree
Fri 24 Jan 2014 6:12PM

Stream is too technical of a name, and should be more welcoming. "Home" is a commonly used term that represents warmth and welcome.

M

maliktunga
Agree
Fri 24 Jan 2014 6:12PM

Stream is too technical of a name, and should be more welcoming. "Home" is a commonly used term that represents warmth and greeting.

M

maliktunga
Agree
Fri 24 Jan 2014 6:13PM

Stream is too technical of a name, it is a misrepresentation (there are more than one stream) and the name should be more welcoming. "Home" is a commonly used term that represents warmth and greeting.

Load More