Loomio

Make Diaspora a Member of the Free Software Support Network

MS maxwell salzberg Public Seen by 152

As Diaspora has grown into a healthy community run Free Software project in the last year, it is time to find a proper home, backed by a non-profit to help it continue to grow. While we can all agree that the community-driven infrastructure is great, there are still a number of things the project cannot directly do without an entity supporting it, such as raising funds.

The past 8 months, Sean and I have been working to find a good home for the assets of Diaspora. One that will support the project’s values, provide a nice structure for dealing with trademarks, copyright, money, and other assets that will ask both in the best interest of, but at the will of the project.

We looked around to our network, trying to find the right place, but one name was at the top of our list: Eben Moglen.

We are lucky that when we asked Professor Moglen for his help, he proposed what was the perfect solution for our community: Diaspora should join the Free Software Support network (http://freesoftwaresupport.org/), an organization that he heads up as a peer organization to the Software Freedom Law Center (http://www.softwarefreedom.org/). The Free Software Support Network operates as a non-profit holding organization for worthy Free Software projects. FSSN helps projects with the paperwork and clerical stuff that hackers generally don’t want to do, like taxes and dealing with banks ( I know you don’t want to do this because I have been dealing with it :)

FSSN gives Diaspora the following:

  1. A respected place to hold all of the assets of Diaspora; the trademarks, the code copyright, JoinDiaspora and our money. It is a transparent organization which acts in the interest of the project and the community. If we decide we want to spend money doing code bounties or give swag to our top contributors, FSSN will let us do what we need to do.

  2. Take tax-free donations. FSSN is a 401c3 charity. Every penny that is donated to FSSN in Diaspora’s name is dog eared for our project. This is huge in keeping the ‘back room’ of Diaspora clear, and means hackers can focus on being hackers without doing the annoying dirty stuff.

  3. A partner that shares our values. Enough said.

What it does not do:

1) Tell us how to run our community

2) Tell us how to write code

3) Change how we create Diaspora.

The only real requirement of the FSSN is that there is a governance structure in place. After a year of experience, it is my belief that we have a great organic structure to make things more codified.

Here’s the course of action we want to take:

1) Make Diaspora a Member of the FSSN

2) Transfer all Diaspora Inc Diaspora related assets to FSSN (Trademark, hosting, Social media accounts)

3) Assign all Diaspora code to the FSSN, and amend our contributor agreement to reflect this change.

To celebrate our first year as a community project, and fill the coffers of our project, and joining the FSSN we also want to run a Crowdhoster campaign for Diaspora(see a work in progress here: https://diaspora.crowdhoster.com/help-take-the-web-to-the-next-level-with-diaspora... will launch on Monday). This money will go directly to the Diaspora project via the FSSN, and we can figure out together the best way to help the project. Since Crowdfunding AND Free software are so essential to the core of what we do, Crowdhoster is a great choice. We will be going for the same goal of 10k, and even have some cool swag made up.

(EDIT: I clarified more what I meant here: https://www.loomio.org/discussions/6353#comment-46047)

(EDIT 2 more thoughts: https://www.loomio.org/discussions/6353#comment-46413)

N

Nick Wed 21 Aug 2013 10:49PM

Actually, I should have said this before, but we need to agree on what our governance is, either before or after this vote, but before actually 'creating' a foundation.
Unless I've missed it somewhere, our governance so far is just 'that we will take decisions on loomio', which isn't sufficient. We need people responsible for ensuring that decisions are acted on, and we need people who will actually implement the decisions about spending money, and all the legal and formal stuff. That probably requires some kind of council and elections...

MS

maxwell salzberg Wed 21 Aug 2013 10:53PM

@nickdowson this legal help and guidance is provided by the FSSN (and through the SFLC) Nothing is mandated by them other than having some stable leadership so they have only a few touchpoints (which could rotate on a stable schedule)

N

Nick Wed 21 Aug 2013 11:00PM

@maxwellsalzberg - regardless, we still need to agree how we are going to do that (are we going to stick with our informal leadership, or are going to actually have a process for that?)

http://libcom.org/library/tyranny-structurelessness-jo-freeman !

G

goob Wed 21 Aug 2013 11:26PM

Apologies for the unclear wording. I'll close this proposal before too many people vote on it and open a new one, as this issue is so crucial that we need absolute clarity. Sorry to those who have already voted; please cast your votes again.

G

Poll Created Wed 21 Aug 2013 11:32PM

Votes on Maxwell's proposals re FSSN and crowd-funding Closed Tue 27 Aug 2013 10:06AM

Outcome
by goob Tue 25 Apr 2017 5:15AM

Looks like everyone's really excited about the FSSN proposal, but it's not quite the right time to fund-raise just yet.

My suggestion is to get the FSSN in place and publicised, and then discuss how and why we can raise funds.

Please read carefully as there are four voting options - make sure you vote for the correct one.

YES - I AGREE with the proposal to join FSSN and transfer ownership and assets of Diaspora to them as described, and I AGREE with the proposal to have a crowd-funding initiative immediately as described.
ABSTAIN - I AGREE with the proposal to join FSSN and transfer ownership and assets of Diaspora to them as described, but I DISAGREE with the proposal to have a crowd-funding initiative immediately as described.
NO - I DISAGREE with the proposal to join FSSN and transfer ownership and assets of Diaspora to them as described, but I AGREE with the proposal to have a crowd-funding initiative immediately as described.
BLOCK - I DISAGREE with the proposal to join FSSN and transfer ownership and assets of Diaspora to them as described, and I DISAGREE with the proposal to have a crowd-funding initiative immediately as described.

Feel free to give reasons/details about your position when voting, as we need absolute clarity about everyone's position on this.

Results

Results Option % of points Voters
Agree 33.3% 16 ST MS TS JR PP R M C SM N FTL A SM DH( DC TA
Abstain 66.7% 32 FS JH T F G DM DS DU T O M D TM D IGM S DU L R SVB
Disagree 0.0% 0  
Block 0.0% 0  
Undecided 0% 79 JL BK DS AA S CB HF BO DM GC JH M EG G AX PC BB LP T DY

48 of 127 people have participated (37%)

MS

maxwell salzberg
Agree
Wed 21 Aug 2013 11:37PM

These are bold moves to move our community forward. If we are going to move forward, we should do it in a big way.

ST

Sean Tilley
Agree
Thu 22 Aug 2013 12:17AM

I think being a part of the FSSN is a huge deal, and if we can do some crowdfunding to coincide with our anniversary and announcement, I think we could make a significant push forward for the project.

SM

Sarah Mei
Agree
Thu 22 Aug 2013 12:25AM

I think this is a positive move, both because it takes work off of Max's plate, and also (more importantly) because it lets all the operational stuff that was previously owned by a corporation be transparent.

DC

dennis collective
Agree
Thu 22 Aug 2013 12:46AM

THIS IS EXCITING! I think it will be great for the fresh young blood running the organization to have the autonomy they deserve. Another Crowd-Funding campaign is exciting because then they will be able to eat burritos, which taste good.

RS

Raphael Sofaer
Abstain
Thu 22 Aug 2013 3:48AM

Agree with the proposal to join FSSN.
Disagree with the proposal to have a crowd-funding initiative. Giving money to Jonne Haß and our other top developers who need it is attractive but it needs concrete goals and people. Who? How will we decide?

Load More