Loomio
Sat 12 Jun 2021 5:47AM

Request for Proposals: NYC Life Sciences Innovation Infrastructure RFP

ID Ibrahim Dulijan Public Seen by 17

Please look up this opportunity NYC Life Sciences Innovation Infrastructure RFP

Many of our community attended the optional informational session will be held virtually on Wednesday, June 30, 2021 at 3:30P.M. In that meeting they clarified their RFP and answered questions from the attendees. Answers to questions emailed after the fact, the list of attendees, and the presentation deck, will be/are posted to their site here.

Also attached is the Vision Plan for NYC Life Sciences.

There are significant challenges in choosing to pursue this RFP because it does not appear at first glance to enable they type of low-cost community access to facilities that BwoB has provided in the past. However the magnitude of the funds marks it as a significant opportunity for a non-profit operator/respondent that can commit themselves to activities that result in the construction of more biotech lab space and programming that supports commercial projects in NYC.

This thread is to discuss the ideas that would go into the responding to this RFP and serve as a organizing tool for those that align to any proposed action regarding the application. Any writing on this RFP may serve to inform future applications or serve as the nucleus for further strategic decisions. To this end, here is a a draft document accessible to those on the community list (and with a Google account, I'm working on a Nextcloud solution for those without such an account).

F

Frank Wed 30 Jun 2021 6:59AM

Thanks for the note. One point to clarify, I do not think your mission statement should be written for the RFP that was my point. I think you stick with your mission statement and write the proposal around it.
I'd like to speak you soon because i had a conversation with a friend about this. He is extremely intelligent. has a phd in biology but has worked mainly as an investor and now is running his second successful startup. He is a great strategist and has always been able to raise money from investors. I asked him about this and he had a tactical suggestion that I thought was a super good idea. it's too much to type out so I need to explain it in a conversation. Let me know if you or the group has time before the 3pm info session .

Item removed

DU

Deleted account Tue 29 Jun 2021 7:08PM

Hi Danny, is there anything I can do to help for Wed?

C.B.

D

Danny Wed 30 Jun 2021 1:04AM

If you are able to articulate your perspective on how the RFP can be used to further the goals of BwoB then you can help by sharing that. Otherwise I appreciate you reading the RFP and providing a short comment.

I was thinking about workshoping questions over Loomio but there isn't much more time to do so before the meeting tomorrow. If I get around to drafting some tonight I will send them as a poll here.

DU

Deleted account Wed 30 Jun 2021 1:29AM

Can we do a quick meeting? I am in the bay but could talk tomorrow if you have a few mins.

C.B.

D

Poll Created Wed 30 Jun 2021 11:47AM

Chat about RFP Closed Wed 30 Jun 2021 7:03PM

Outcome
by Danny Wed 30 Jun 2021 7:08PM

After a little confusion we had our short-notice meeting at ~18:00-20:00.

We talked about many things related to BwoB's future and the RFP (and even a little digression into Open Insulin) and agreed that we will set our meetings more frequently for a time to write the RFP. I believe the most important take away from this meeting is our conception of the RFP as primarily driven by NYC's desire to create more lab space which aligns with our interests to (re)open our lab space. There are likely fundamentally flawed assumptions on how this lab space might function to create jobs and empower those with biotechnology but for the purposes of writing this grant we will have to endow the story of impact we are trying to sell to the NYCEDC the full priority of our efforts.

Some of the meeting was spent catching Vik up to the thoughts that we covered at the last Community Meeting. Which included the need to find a strategic niche in our application among what will be various business incubator-type RFPs replicating Harlem Biospace and Genspace. We are most excited about a story involving unincorporated individuals as an untapped resource of innovative ideas and putting them on the path (should they seek it) of commercialization.

We also aligned that not all decisions during this process will be debated asynchronously because we need the focus on telling a compelling story and we need to move a little faster to meet the Aug 18th deadline. In my mind we're thinking that all comments should be properly formulated objections (although I recognize that not everyone is aligned to the consent process). Stay tuned for our next meeting invite about this over Loomio we are aiming for sometime Monday morning.

There is some interest is speaking about the RFP. I can't meet before hand but we can chat immediately afterwards. Keep in mind there is also window for formal questions to the RFP if the meeting does not give us the insights we are seeking. These must be submitted by email before July 28.

Let me know a time that works for you today.

Window to discuss RFP Wednesday, June 30 · 6:00 – 8:00pm

Google Meet joining info

Results

UTC Votes D DU
Wed 30 Jun 2021 10:00PM
2
 
 
Wed 30 Jun 2021 10:30PM
2
 
 
Wed 30 Jun 2021 11:00PM
1
 
 
Wed 30 Jun 2021 11:30PM
1
 
 

2 of 4 people have participated (50%)

F

Frank Wed 30 Jun 2021 4:03PM

I must have miscommunicated because I meant I wanted to have a quick chat today before the information session with the city or right afterwards. at this point afterwards would be more realistic . So let's say sometime before the end of the week

Item removed

Item removed

Item removed

Load More