Loomio
Tue 7 Nov 2017 6:31PM

Citation of Preprints

TN Tom Narock Public Seen by 439

EarthArXiv allows an author to upload updated versions of their preprint. For instance, an author may submit an initial preprint, receive feedback, and choose to upload a revised version of that preprint. The way EarthArXiv is implemented, all versions of a preprint remain on the server and are assigned the same DOI. This is design choice by the Center for Open Science and not something that can be easily changed. One implication of this is that citing a preprint is not straightforward. The DOI is not enough to uniquely identify a preprint as other versions with the same DOI may exist in the future. A simple workaround would be to recommend a citation style that includes the DOI and a "last accessed" value similar to how we cite web pages. We may also want to recommend "preprint" be included so that it is obvious from a citation that the work has not been peer reviewed. I think it would be good if we got out ahead of this issue and starting thinking collectively how preprints should be cited

CJ

Christopher Jackson Mon 27 Nov 2017 8:35PM

Same reply as Stephanie. It's a good idea to get ahead of things if, in future, submissions of this type are likely to increase.

SL

Sabine Lengger Mon 27 Nov 2017 9:00PM

We could loosely base them on Pangaea recommendations? https://wiki.pangaea.de/wiki/Citation

B

brandon Thu 4 Jan 2018 10:59AM

+1 @sabinelengger Also, FORCE11 have recommendations for software/code---and there was a group in ESIP looking into this as well (Soren was leading, if memory serves), but I haven't followed up with that effort in some time.